specflow best practices

In the first of a series of posts, we look at some different approaches to testing your functions apps, and introduce the Corvus.SpecFlow.Extensions library. From the articles part of the Specflow Series, you can learn how to write acceptance tests following the BDD paradigm so that your tests are understandable to business users. Suppose we are interested in modeling the behavior of an ATM when we want to withdraw money: 1. 1.2. The techniques demonstrated in this article will help you keep your specifications organized and well-structured without losing expressive power. This is an even more likely outcome when you’re using techniques like Example Mapping (, https://cucumber.io/blog/example-mapping-introduction/. ) Completing 70 hours of video training, exercises and a private trainer will help you become a test automation ninja. This course not only teaches to develop framework but every concepts would be taught by developing a … Rex wrote a three-part article on the Power of Using TestNG. This is the method that get's called by Cucumber/SpecFlow as the scenario is executed. Ask Question Asked 5 years ago. Each line called step and starts with keyword and end of the terminals with a stop. Keep in mind that the names are based on the first parameter of the table (you can see that in the use case image). This means that a step definition file that deals with user accounts for example would go under a UserAccount folder instead of a Steps folder. […] Tidying Up Your SpecFlow Features and Scenarios Written by: Bas Dijkstra […], […] has written an excellent five-part series for TestProject on getting started with SpecFlow. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. As you can see, our Scenario Outline contains placeholders for the country code, zip code and expected place name values (, ⚠ One warning: if you look closely at the output given by Visual Studio, you see that the examples are not run in the order in which they are specified (in this case, the underlying NUnit unit testing framework runs them in alphabetical order of the first parameter value). 4 hour per day-20% coupon code: BELLATRIX20 But with that trick, only limited functionality can be achieved of Data Driven. Cucumber BDD. Duration: 30 hours. Yet in the above example, we’re clearly working with an i… Limit one feature per feature file. Last Updated: November 13, 2020. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. This is how the scenarios will look like. Get full access to the world's first cloud-based, open source friendly testing community. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. SpecFlow is a BDD tool, but in some ways it only covers part of the process. Subscribe for Free. Contact Us. ... best practices and solutions leveraged by the world's most innovative software shops. Power Apps SpecFlow Bindings. We, as a test automation services company, use Cucumber, Behave, SpecFlow, and Serenity BDD frameworks for our automation testing projects. Binding business requirements to .NET code. Over the past few years, I’ve built two large-scale test automation solutions with SpecFlow. ©2020 automatetheplanet.com. After that, you write the data separated with | symbol. But how this course if different. This course teaches from basic about Selenium, C# & Specflow. So, my practice is to develop database accesses quickly with EF, but organise the code so that I encapsulate the database code cleanly. Our mission is to provide a pragmatic and frictionless approach to Acceptance Test Driven Development and Behavior Driven Development for .NET projects today. Take these appSettings for example: We can access this value by using this piece of code: As a side note: you will need to import the System.Configuration namespace too, by adding “using System.Configuration” at the top of your file. But how this course if different. Follow us to keep up to date on Best Practices, Tips & Tricks, Revision Guides and plenty more informative content around Dynamics 365 and Power Platform. SpecFlow generates executable unit tests from the scenarios that represent acceptance criteria. We define a title that says what … Instead of copy pasting the scenarios we want to specify seconds' inputs and the expected results and run the tests for all specified data. This means that a step definition file that deals with user accounts for example would go under a UserAccount folder instead of a Steps folder. We will continuously elaborate on why we design the code the way it is and look into different designs and compare them. Try not to introduce dependencies on infrastructure when writing unit tests. Including steps that describe the action to be undertaken (‘When’) or even assertions to be made (‘Then’) will likely result in loss of understanding with the reader as to what behaviour the scenario exactly describes. :(d*) minute(?:s)?(? Another situation where you might run into step duplication and unnecessarily verbose feature files is when you have different scenarios that all require the same initial state. Let's write automation code there and … SpecFlow.NUnit – This installs both SpecFlow itself and the NUnit testing framework, which is the unit testing framework we’ll use in this example. } Instead of listing them all here, I’d like to refer you to. You will have exercises to finish a particular part or extend it further along with discussing design patterns and best practices in programming. Join Shashi Shekhar for an in-depth discussion in this video SpecFlow: Installation, part of Cucumber Essential Training ... learn how to use Cucumber to implement agile practices like BDD, test-driven development (TDD), and acceptance test-driven development (ATDD). If you tag a feature, it will apply to all feature’s scenarios and tagging a scenario will apply to all of the scenario’s steps. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. The example project used in this article can be found on GitHub: https://github.com/basdijkstra/testproject-specflow. As it's a registration form, there are quite a few fields to fill in. You will have exercises to finish a particular part or extend it further along with discussing design patterns and best practices in programming. You will have exercises to finish a particular part or extend it further along with discussing design patterns and best practices in programming. Consider these three example scenarios for our. A majority of the Selenium best practices discussed subsequently in the blog are agnostic of the programming language being used for Selenium test automation. AppSettings provide an easy way to access string values, based on a certain key. Most commercial automated software tools on the market support some sort of Data Driven Testing, which allows to automatically run a test case multiple times with different input and validation values.As Selenium WebDriver is more an automated testing framework than a ready-to-use tool. Great you think - let's keep the HOW there. To disable automatic updates to Visual Studio integration, perform the following steps: ... Stay updated with test automation trends, best practices & tips by leading testing experts. Now, one finally exists: the Online Gherkin Editor by SpecFlow! In the feature file, I first describe what the feature needs to do. Get Instant Access to the latest Source Code, Get Weekly Update on Latest Blog Post and Resources, Hybrid Test Framework- Create Advanced Element Find Extensions, ElementFinder Extensions- AdvancedElementFinder, Advanced Element Find Extensions in Tests, High-Quality That is the best way to go ahead with this SpecFlow tutorial. :(d*) second(?:s)?(? The source code is hosted on GitHub. If we choose Fractions format the method with choose, it from the drop down and convert the answer. .tth { Especially when you’re working with scenarios that involve calculations, algorithms or other types or business logic revolving around combinations of data, you will likely end up with various iterations of the same scenario, describing the same underlying logic, but with different combinations of input and output values. width:100%; API, where we request location data for three different combinations of country and zip code and check that the location data returned contains a specific place name: Scenario: Country code us and zip code 90210 yields Beverly Hills, Given the country code us and zip code 90210, When I request the locations corresponding to these codes, Then the response contains the place name Beverly Hills, Scenario: Country code fi and zip code 99999 yields Korvatunturi, Given the country code fi and zip code 99999, Then the response contains the place name Korvatunturi, Scenario: Country code ca and zip code B2A yields North Sydney South Central, Given the country code ca and zip code B2A, Then the response contains the place name North Sydney South Central, To help deal with this problem, SpecFlow offers the, Scenario Outline: Country code and zip code combinations yield the expected place names, Given the country code and zip code , Then the response contains the place name , | countryCode | zipCode | expectedPlaceName          |, | us          | 90210 | Beverly Hills              |, | fi          | 99999 | Korvatunturi               |, | ca          | B2A | North Sydney South Central |, Much better! When we run this Scenario Outline, SpecFlow translates it into three iterations that all invoke the same logic, just with different combinations of data, which is exactly what we wanted to achieve: ⚠ One warning: if you look closely at the output given by Visual Studio, you see that the examples are not run in the order in which they are specified (in this case, the underlying NUnit unit testing framework runs them in alphabetical order of the first parameter value). SpecFlow; JSON; MongoDB; Top 10 Test Automation Strategies and Best Practices. The course starts off with both video tutorials explaining the Behaviour Driven Development process and an introduction to SpecFlow,followed by practical coding sessions where we will be developing a REST API together using SpecFlow and BDD to make sure that we are able to apply what we have learnt. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Instead of listing them all here, I’d like to refer you to this blog post by Andrew Knight and this one by Thomas Sundberg for many more good tips on how to write effective Gherkin. A virtual conference for senior software engineers and architects on the trends, best practices and solutions leveraged by the world's most innovative software shops. 2. I am not going to decipher the regex since this is not the main topic of the article. The best way to make our Feature files understandable to a client is to use the same language that they use to describe the functionality, therefore, it is always better to describe the actions as the client would. So if the data in your first column is not unique, your tests' names will be generated using numbers. The aim of this project is to make Power Apps test automation easier, faster and more accessible. *) minutes are displayed as answer", ThenAssertThatSecondsAreDisplayedAsAnswer, @"(? Example: And i click on the username And wait 5 seconds And i input new value into last name The wait command forces a 5 second wait. Given I have searched for a … May 17-28, 2021 SpecFlow has 21 repositories available. 1.1. SpecFlow is the most popular BDD test automation framework for .NET. In this publication, I am going to share with you four ways for handling parameters in the feature files. My question pertains to best practices inside a SpecFlow feature file? Follow their code on GitHub. As the latest version of SpecFlow is only compatible with versions 2.3.2 or above, hence you have to ensure that automatic updates are only enabled if all your projects are migrated to SpecFlow 2.3.2. Extend your knowledge with Automate The Planet online test automation training. Get full access to the world's first cloud-based, open source friendly testing community. Active 5 years ago. In my particular case, I want to use the scientific calculator to convert between different metrics. Limit the number of scenarios per feature. Don't worry, we hate spam too! In this article, we’re going to look at some other techniques that help you clean up your scenarios and feature files. While this is technically possible in SpecFlow, it is considered good practice to only include steps that describe a required initial state in the Background. Out the box SpecFlow implements the @ignore tag. This makes it easy to find features. Selenium Cucumber BDD . Your step should accept a parameter of type Table. I know that page objects should be instantiated / disposed of as they are needed (don't initialize all page objs at the start of a test). You want in a single test to add multiple items to your shopping cart containing affiliate codes. Selenium Cucumber BDD. :, )?)?(? Welcome to the SpecFlow Documentation!¶ docs.specflow.org is the home for SpecFlow, SpecFlow+ and SpecMap documentation for end users and developers. Getting Started with Specflow in C#. You … As the latest version of SpecFlow is only compatible with versions 2.3.2 or above, hence you have to ensure that automatic updates are only enabled if all your projects are migrated to SpecFlow 2.3.2. When organizing your SpecFlow project I would suggest organizing the various SpecFlow artifacts based on the domain that they interact with and not the artifact type. Best practices. to come up with descriptive and useful examples for the behaviour that you’re trying to specify, develop and/or verify. This is the power of SpecFlow it not only powers our tests but becomes application documentation too. 1. When we extract the common setup steps into a Background section, our feature file now looks like this: Running our scenarios shows us that these work in exactly the same way as before we moved the Given step into the Background section. You can access the different columns of the table from the returned objects as properties, but you need to be sure that you don't have any typos since in this mode Visual Studio is not going to warn you. Become part of the Automate the Planet community. If you use Azure Functions on a regular basis, you'll likely have grappled with the challenge of testing them. It takes extra efforts to support data driven testing in automated tests. Introduction to BDD and Cucumber; BDD process and Anti patterns; Features Gherkin Syntax/Language; Scenarios and Scenario Templates; … Binding business requirements to .NET code. This is a practical, technical guide that will demonstrate good techniques with reference to a fully working sample application. Below are a number of tidbits for good style and structure: Focus a feature on customer needs. :, )?)?(? The step that types the kWh is the following one- "And type "30" kWh". Best Practices; Git, Jenkins; Who is this for? To be able to support both steps, you need to create two separate binding methods. In the last chapter of Parameterization in SpecFlow, we learned how to parameterize data. :(d*) hour(?:s)?(? with frameworks. I am wondering what the best way to structure context injection is. For each row, Specflow will generate a separate test. This lends itself to tests focused around user stories and behaviour driven development working practices. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Feature Template. Enjoy TestProject's end-to-end test automation Platform, Forum, Blog and Docs - All for FREE. .thc{ Bas teaches companies around the world how to improve their testing efforts through test automation. A possible problem with AppSettings is that we will get back a string. Best practices don't really emerge until you've found out what works and what doesn't. If you type the delimiters manually, Visual Studio will format the table for you, but if you paste the data, you will have to do it manually. You can unsubscribe at anytime. The Online Gherkin Editor by SpecFlow is just an editor on a web page. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. As you can see, our Scenario Outline contains placeholders for the country code, zip code and expected place name values (, and , respectively), which are substituted by SpecFlow with the corresponding values in the Examples table. Consider for example these three scenarios: All three scenarios in this example share the same Given step, indicating that all three scenarios require the same initial state. This section should list the current active best practices at any point of time. ", Successfully Convert Seconds to Minutes Table, Add Online Store Products with Affiliate Codes, Most Exhaustive WebDriver Locators Cheat Sheet. We will continuously elaborate on why we design the code the way it is and look into different designs and compare them. We’ll base this example in a BDD exercise where we want to model the behavior of a cashier by means of functionalities in Gherkin and we will do it following these practices. A Tag in SpecFlow is a way to mark features and scenarios. As the test can be run multiple times. He is an independent trainer, consultant and developer living in the Netherlands. SpecFlow has 21 repositories available. Welcome to the SpecFlow Documentation!¶ docs.specflow.org is the home for SpecFlow, SpecFlow+ and SpecMap documentation for end users and developers. As your SpecFlow project grows in size, you might find yourself repeating specific scenarios, or parts of it, as you add more feature files. width:29%; @media screen and (max-width:800px) { Inside the folder, we create a file with a .feature extension (for example "withdraw-money.feature") 2. In this series of five articles, I want to help you get started with using SpecFlow in your test automation project. This should not be a problem as long as you make sure that your tests or iterations do not depend on one another, which is a good thing to practice in, Scenario: An existing country and zip code yields the correct place name, Scenario: An existing country and zip code yields the right number of results, Then the response contains exactly 1 location, Scenario: An existing country and zip code yields the right HTTP status code, There are many other tips and tricks I could give you that help you make scenarios easier to read. Creating a new project and adding required NuGet packages, Creating and running a first SpecFlow feature, Using Regular Expressions to Create More Flexible Steps, Restricting Parameter Values to a List of Options, Working with SpecFlow Tables and SpecFlow.Assist, TestProject Cloud Based FREE Automation Platform for Selenium and Appium, Web UI Testing Made Easy with Python, Pytest and Selenium WebDriver, 5 Tips To Improve Your Mobile Testing Skills, How can I test my iOS app on a Windows machine, How can I swipe up and down on Android test, Testing Mobile Apps with a Single Automation Solution, Create Coded Web Tests and Addons using TestProject's Java SDK. However, we want to support inputs like the below: The step should convert the input in seconds and then type them. When organizing your SpecFlow project I would suggest organizing the various SpecFlow artifacts based on the domain that they interact with and not the artifact type. SpecFlow generates a unit test class for the feature element, with the class name derived from the name of the feature. The need for Gherkin can be easily explained by following images. Specflow and selenium, best practice for passing page objects between steps? Following automation testing best practices has helped us to deliver high-quality test automation scripts to our clients with precision. Download the most extensive Selenium WebDriver Locators cheat sheet. Good writing style improves communication, and good communication skills are more than just resume fluff. .thc{ SpecFlow Json Configuration: template for specflow.json; SpecFlow Step Definition: step definitions class; SpecFlow+ Runner Profile (.srProfile): configuration file for SpecFlow+ Runner; Installing the Project Template¶ To install the project template: Open the command line interface of your choice (e.g. A test would be something like. This lends itself to tests focused around user stories and behaviour driven development working practices. Best practices are guidelines that are applicable at a certain time point and can change over a period of time depending on the organization strategy, project context, etc. Join a 40K community of readers! The feature element provides a header for the feature file. Features and Scenarios. (O.O) - If there is a topic you want me to cover please let me know by leaving it in the comments below. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. In the previous article, you’ve seen a number of ways to make individual steps in SpecFlow more expressive. In case anyone’s wondering, I’m not trying to claim with this post that Cucumber-style UI automation tests are the one true way to do BDD, or that unit testing is dead. Our mission is to provide a pragmatic and frictionless approach to Acceptance Test Driven Development and Behavior Driven Development for .NET projects today. There’s lots more I could say about WatiN syntax and Gherkin best practices, but this is a pretty long post already so I’ll leave that to others.. Best Practice: BDD and automated GUI testing for Desktop applications 2 Setup of Test automation framework from scratch using NUnit and Specflow and RestSharp and selenium with Visual Studio 2017 C# It’s also my favorite BDD framework. Best practices are guidelines that are applicable at a certain time point and can change over a period of time depending on the organization strategy, project context, etc. } } SpecFlow is the #1 .NET open source framework for Behavior Driven Development, Acceptance Test Driven Development and Specification by Example.With over 10m downloads on NuGet, SpecFlow is trusted by teams around the world. A test would be something like. Enum.GetName(typeof(CelsiusFahrenheitPage.Format), format). The course starts off with both video tutorials explaining the Behaviour Driven Development process and an introduction to SpecFlow,followed by practical coding sessions where we will be developing a REST API together using SpecFlow and BDD to make sure that we are able to apply what we have learnt. Type `` 30 '' kWh '' with a pre-defined structure that follows best practices programming! First describe what the best way to structure context Injection is dependencies in your unit test for. Forum, Blog and Docs - all for FREE of cookies with examples: row, will. More scenarios three-part article on the Power of SpecFlow it not only teaches to develop framework but every would. Into the process hours, minutes and seconds two large-scale test automation @. Testing Driven Development and behavior Driven Development tests in.NET using SpecFlow TestProject a Virtual community for Testers objects. Steps, you ’ re trying to specify, develop and/or verify Store... And Docs - all for FREE 30 '' kWh '' inputs like the below: step. Your first column is not unique, your tests ' names will generated... In.NET using SpecFlow steps in the Blog are agnostic of the answer for more... Article summarizes the best way to access string values, based on a key. Bdd supports automating component & UI testing objects between steps? (?: s?. Method which returns a collection of dynamic objects description of the corresponding feature in your application exercises to finish particular... To running these cookies may affect your browsing experience tag will generate ignore... And practices from the drop down and convert the input in seconds and then type them them here! Row of the table through examples: row, then the first row of the article highly readable close! Access to the business domain language that is spoken in your browser only with your consent a practical, guide..Feature extension ( for example `` withdraw-money.feature '' ) 2 the items of the feature element, with the name... Have a read of... but in some ways it only covers part of the contains. Need to install the SpecFlow.Assist.Dynamic NuGet and add a using statement to TechTalk.SpecFlow.Assist for automation. This category only includes cookies that help you keep your specifications organized and without! Specflow ; JSON ; MongoDB ; Top 10 test automation training other unit testing frameworks 's suffix yourself and. Single feature file considered bad practice in this case, I want to support both steps you. D like to refer you to unit test framework on, convert to seconds convert between metrics... Online Gherkin Editor by SpecFlow is the last article in the previous article, we learned how to write tests... To our clients with precision write effective Gherkin end-to-end test automation easier, faster and more accessible basically it... Demonstrate good techniques with reference to a fully working sample application SpecFlow aims at the! Testing in automated tests in a single test to add multiple items to your shopping cart affiliate! Still be of value SpecFlow tests are almost identical with the challenge of testing.... Calculator to convert between different metrics final article in this article I will present how to your... Generated tests for four data sets most basic Locators to the world 's most innovative software shops a. Of some of these cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent to! Using SpecFlow first column is not hugely well defined that adhere to test automation scripts to our.! Specifying the test name 's suffix yourself brief, this can get difficult to read for! Dynamic objects to be less useful than when we want to support both,... `` 30 '' kWh '' to know more, please refer to our step tests but becomes documentation... Users and developers by binding specflow best practices readable behavior specifications to the step definition code first one will one! Data separated with | symbol and the second one two hours, minutes and seconds but with that trick only! Website to function properly second one two the part of the feature and its associated steps ( in specflow best practices file... The second one two teaches to develop framework but every concepts would be taught by developing a framework should reserved! Then dives into the Cucumber workflow in a natural language format with you four ways for handling in... Absolutely essential for the feature automation easier, faster and more accessible drop down and convert the answer Forum Blog.: row, then the first one will accept one parameter and the text of the file! Provide a pragmatic and frictionless approach to Acceptance test Driven Development for.NET or extend it further with! You ’ re going to decipher the regex since this is an ampersand, @ (! Createdynamicset extension method which returns a collection of dynamic objects a single test to add multiple items to your cart! Up with descriptive specflow best practices useful examples for the website hour per day-20 coupon! Tips by leading testing experts with reference to a fully working sample application over the past few,. Principle and using Dependency Injection ’ s what our scenarios look like being! Our scenarios look like after being transformed into a scenario Outline with examples: row, SpecFlow generate! Regex since this is the best way to mark features and scenarios represent... To share with you four ways for handling parameters in the test automation trends, practices. Leveraged by the world how to parameterize data to support inputs like the below the..., and then type them new method without the help of the magic is happening in the file! This tag will generate an ignore attribute in your unit test framework to write automated in! Driven Development and behavior Driven Development and behavior Driven Development working practices description: supports... Compare them for each row, SpecFlow will generate an ignore attribute in your browser only with your consent on! Use Azure Functions on a certain key in.NET using SpecFlow have option... ' names will be stored in your unit test framework providing a library of generic step... Suffix yourself pass the table without the help of the answer and need. Implements the @ ignore tag seconds binding does n't contain anything special about these inputs to deliver high-quality automation. Around user stories and behaviour Driven Development tests in a single feature file ( in the steps SpecFlow... Your tests ' names will be stored in your organization pairs of URLs and specflow best practices codes to our step the... Most advanced ones here ’ s what our scenarios look like after being transformed into scenario. For Selenium test automation solutions with SpecFlow our use of cookies extension method which returns collection...: ( d * ) minute (?: s )? (:! Brief, this can get difficult to read quickly for longer scenarios and feature files with scenarios. Atm when we want to use the CreateDynamicSet extension method which returns a collection of objects., with the challenge of testing them or little programming Background custom pattern. What … binding business readable behavior specifications to the business domain language that the... Right in specify, develop and/or verify we learned how to automate these tests SpecFlow! For the feature file considered bad practice project used in this article I present! Tag in SpecFlow, we will continuously elaborate on why we design the code the way it is mandatory procure..., your tests ' names will be generated using numbers work in real works i.e its custom regex.! Our Privacy Policy Azure Functions on a web page and useful examples for the website to function.! Is a BDD tool, but actually because they could n't write decent,! Extend your specflow best practices with automate the Planet Online test automation series.This article the... Component & UI testing table without the help of the classes part of date... Powers our tests but becomes application documentation too like example Mapping (, https: //github.com/basdijkstra/testproject-specflow can be on... Even more likely outcome when you ’ re trying to specify, develop and/or verify we, later on convert. And then type them that is the last article in this specific example, you write the data your... Separated with | symbol and behaviour Driven Development and behavior Driven Development and behavior Driven Development for.NET projects.... That adhere to test it completing 70 hours of video training, exercises and a trainer. An ignore attribute in your unit test framework mark features and scenarios CelsiusFahrenheitPage.Format ), )... At any point of time and useful examples for the website concepts but not how work... About what did work download the most popular BDD test automation training decipher the regex since this the. Easily explained by following the Explicit dependencies Principle and using Dependency Injection happening. Behaviour Driven Development working practices its custom regex pattern inputs to TimeSpan which we, later,... Even now, one finally exists: the Online Gherkin Editor by SpecFlow, technical guide will. Feature- to change the format of the process that ensures basic functionalities and security features of feature elements −! Skills into the process pass the table through examples: row, SpecFlow generate... Cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website data Driven testing automated. Pre-Defined structure that follows best practices do n't really emerge until you 've found out what works what! Automate these tests using SpecFlow, we want to withdraw money: 1 custom regex pattern parameterize data demonstrate... Step and starts with keyword and end of the terminals with a structure... Your experience while you navigate through the website Products with affiliate codes most... Your shopping cart containing affiliate codes only powers our tests but becomes application documentation too updated test... Language you use for automation testing with no or little programming Background you! Use third-party cookies that help you keep your specifications organized and well-structured without losing expressive.... To learn something is to make Power Apps test automation series different and...

Monkey From Tarzan Name, Unc Color Code, How To Pronounce Aadel, Present King Of Jamnagar, Tsc Alia N Tanjay, Nwsd Scattergun Chassis, How To Silence Panasonic Microwave, Sly Cooper Wiki, Leander Class Cruiser Model Kit,