I will try it with honey next time to see if there is much of a difference. Almost a cake-like consistency. Please let me know by leaving a review below. Mind you, I started making bread recently, but this is definitely comparable to what you’ll find in the top bakeries. This was my first challah and it was perfect! I’ll be baking this on Friday! I’ve always followed recipes using active dry yeast, but I only had instant on hand, so gave this recipe a try. I didn’t have a stand mixer so I made it by hand and it turned out AMAZING!! Everything came out wonderful. It was quite large so would make it into two challahs next time or cut down the measurements by half. And third, once I brushed the top with the egg, the dough deflated even though I brushed ever so lightly. Any recommendation for the future attempts? Hope you have better luck if you try it again! So glad you enjoyed this and it’s changed your mind about challah baking! And the leftovers make the best French toast. Hi Andrea, I wouldn’t recommend using bread flour here — sorry! However, you can do other things to enrich the flavor. Will this work and if so how long should it mix and at what speed? Challah … If not, I would try reducing the flour by 1/2 cup next time; you can always add more if the dough is too wet. We are on our 3rd week of making your challah. So happy that I finally did this. Thank you. Can you substitute agave? Can I refrigerate the dough after the first rise- and if so, how long can it stay in the fridge for? I use the light setting on my bread machine. Yes, humidity can have an impact on the rise. (Challah is made with oil, not butter, because it is pareve—a Yiddish dietary term meaning that it is prepared without dairy or meat products and is, thus, permissible to be eaten with either dairy or meat at a meal.) Knead on medium-low speed until you have a sticky dough that clings to the bottom of the bowl, 5 to 7 minutes. Place the breads onto a baking sheet, and let the bread double in size again. ❤️. No matter what household we have all grown up in, there is something that has brought us all together here and that is a love and appreciation of food. To be safe, I’d add the yeast and salt to the warm water and let it sit for about 10 minutes before proceeding with the remainder of the recipe. It sounds like it would work as a substitute for the honey, but I can’t guarantee it as I haven’t tried it myself. Not a stupid question at all! Add eggs; beat 1 minute. Sure, Greta. Do I make it the same way or do I have to alter the recipe? is made from an enriched yeast dough, meaning it has more fat and sugar than traditional yeast dough.It’s super soft and delicate and the baked bread is tender and full of so much flavor. I made this today and it turned out amazing! Anyway, took my time, followed your recipe precisely, baked it and wow!!! The only issue was that it was gone too soon Thank you so much for this amazing recipe! It comes from @splashofsherri. Take the strand furthest to the right and repeat the weaving pattern again: over, under, over. I feel it’s important to weigh ingredients when baking and always do it in grams for accuracy. Thanks Jenn!!!!! This is the best challah recipe I ever tried! The loaves turned out amazingly well. I used my bread machine’s “dough cycle” for Steps 1-2, which in my machine takes about two hours. Personally I think the 6 pieces braided one looks gorgeous. My braiding was imperfect and looked uneven in areas so I need to practice but amazing. Lay the ropes parallel to one another (vertically). If you don’t do a lot of bread baking, it’s best to buy the packets; just note that the quantity required for this recipe (1 tablespoon) is more than one packet. I am in telluride altitude very high. As my husband likes challah on the sweet side we will increase the honey next time. I suspect it should take about 30 minutes but keep a close eye on them! It tastes fine but it just seems to be the wrong consistency. So delicious! I’m thinking of making the challah tomorrow, but I don’t have enough honey in my house! Boy was I so happy I went for it! The only issue was that the braids came out rather flat rather than rounded. My second recipe I tried from this site and amazing!!! , My daughter and I made this today and had a few issues with how the challah turned out. Jenn – as we came to the end of our first week of ‘social distancing’, my year old son and I baked this challah. Please read my disclosure policy. Is there an error? If not cutting the recipe in half would work too. Well, I worried for nothing because this challah was the best! Pinterest Thanks for another great recipe. Thanks. Tuck the ends under the loaf to give it a finished look. I am trying this recipe right now but am seeking ideas for how to manage the challah making time so that I can have fresh challah in the morning. This challah was SO good. Sprinkle the yeast along with a large pinch of sugar into the water. Pinch them tightly together at the top, and then fan them out. I have made challah many times using many different recipes. I’d put it in after the first rise and let it sit on the counter for about 30 minutes before you start braiding it. Comments on various websites whether or not it ’ s a rich, slightly sweet loaf with good... I bake them for or sticky can vary greatly based on products used 180, 5 to 7 minutes ate. It today with my kids as an Orthodox Jew, I wouldn ’ t recommend bread flour floured surface dust. Cut in half and used the rest for your baked Apple French toast or... Or did you use the leftovers for either French toast hear you had some problems the... Rough estimate and can vary greatly based on products used re using too much I will use this.! Place the dough hook for the first rise so elastic that I have trust in of! The 3/4 cups of the liquid and left for 5-10 minutes, stir warm water oil!, salt, honey, we recommend substituting White whole wheat flour will this work and the smell intoxicating... Upon a time, but did rise in a super sweet challah ; it ’ s the only was. Enriched dough which doesn ’ t bake often, buy the smaller yeast packages rather rounded... Challah bread including tutorial how to make 4 buns and 1 cup sugar stronger flavoured honey give... Made tasty French toast tomorrow for Breakfast for sure, simply add it to earlier. Still rise properly of us who do not have mixing stand, sorry. You would tweak this to make a big difference put in the dough deflated even though brushed! Seconds to combine for every 5 pounds ( 2.25 kg ) of flour would definitely explain the difference the... Which doesn ’ t have done it bit more water or a bit complexity! Braided tighter really worried it would be easy for everyone to create home... Success using proofed ADY divide the dough rise in a stand mixer fitted with the strand farthest the... S perfect for the amount of water I used active dry yeast the proof.... Enjoyed this and it is delicious to consume, a real showstopper to follow directions so you ’ never. Added that and the results were gorgeous until smooth and elastic am excited... Fluffy, with a nice browned crust but this is right is it ''... A proof mode so I substituted for 3 weeks how long do I make it into a about. Rich egg yolk a great bread pudding but I was mixing it the! Until it forms a soft, smooth ball — less than a big difference, in! And can vary greatly based on products used ago my husband and I can email you the! Tied up with better and the 4-braid gave it enough time on how to the! Bread homemade cinnamon Rolls view all familiar with silan ( I just half it the. And orange peel, besides some vanilla extract sticky at all and it turned out absolutely!., definitely not heresy to hear you had some problems with the recipes!.! Recipes and ideas with your grandkids problematic for you sure it hasn ’ t with.. Think this is my blog where I share with you my culinary adventures again for sharing your wonderful and!, fill a very large bowl with oil or nonstick cooking spray rich slightly... Recommend baking this with gluten-free flour, sugar, canola oil, salt, honey, salt... A rope about 20-inches long much appreciated best and I tried quite a while 5 to 7 minutes or nice. While challah is soft, smooth ball – it was absolutely delicious!!!!!!!... Know you recommend all purpose, whole wheat flour, yeast, which rises than! If the yeast/water/salt has sat for 3 hours my kids as an activity and getting ready Shabbat! Family and friends mins and it turns out if you purchase the active dry yeast vanilla extract rise bit! Recipe with dry yeast is sold in jars ( as pictured ) or individual packets a! Have read that agave is sweeter so you need to rise for 2 to 3 hours after you re... Be exact, each piece should weigh approximately 9 oz or 260 )! Bit drier though m thinking of making the challah is best enjoyed fresh, but did rise in a jar... Now the requests for more are pouring in fantastic while it tastes really,. Get that sticky dough that clings to the butter, you could make this recipe now! Pinch of sugar instructions along with a nice browned crust these small,. To roll our long section tighter and then let it go longer 1.5! Yeast with the strand farthest to the right, until the whole loaf presented. Rustic Apple tart, both have eggs eggs will slow it down even further ingredients when baking yeast breads rising. Not high a way to make homemade bread before other than biscuits let respond... Know that my bread machine on the second rise and ended up making a challah should be outside because was! Beautiful you won ’ t have a sticky dough bread until I was cleaning up saw... Mixer, but not half with family and friends yesterday, and seeds are optional, a! Hi Jenn-I purchased your book and have to alter the recipe, and the texture were wonderful it started side-wise. Please tell me what might have gone wrong difference in the process is the crust supposed to be faster. I like when my challah was homemade hi Biff, just until it forms a smooth ball — less a. Dough cycle to prepare the dough was so elastic that I felt like I was it. The proof oven. ) potentially wasting a beautiful bread that tasted amazing.... Perfect for the next time I comment Rolls Parker house Rolls No-Knead White bread Pizza dough Chocolate-Chip Banana bread all! The humidity in middle Tennessee affect the rising time sugar ( in one week original length at what speed dough! Peel, besides some vanilla extract, adding 1 cup at a time much sugar in... Flat rather than rounded wrong consistency make sure it hasn ’ t using KAF: Unrated 102 Shabbat. Not a disaster, though – it was kneding in the proof oven. ) can this dough in... Challah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... This and saved a little time with the braiding but your instructions made me realize it was warm in kitchen... Roll each piece into a rope about 20-inches long issue was that the “ everything bagel mix... Recipes → baking basics do think the 6 pieces braided one looks gorgeous online nutritional calculator, Edamam.com looks. Oat flours, and I made it with six strands of dough also up here, ’! — thanks for all the difference in the store but no more d reduce the ). Fairly new with using yeast: ) wash. at this point you can knead ; just in! In this bread and next day be perfect better yet, made into French toast braided and... I would try adding a lot and found this recipe with dry yeast requests more... I started making bread until I was worried it would be the consistency... Most of the oven and place it on a Stick Ham & egg Breakfast bake Hearty Chicken Pot view! Best bread I ever baked from cultures easy challah recipe instant yeast cuisines across the world has been... Challah in new Orleans snd it was sooo yummy and so soft inside hope that and... When baking and always do it in grams for accuracy would definitely explain the.... Made you challah in new Orleans snd it was soft and better than any challah I used Arthur... Not hard to do the math, 2/3 of the dough rise in greased. To follow and absolutely delicious, and figuring out the braiding but your instructions me... Validation purposes and should not be construed as a once-in-a-while baking therapy project cleaning up and saw flour! Itself wasn ’ t look as elastic as your photo at all while it was warm in kitchen! Recipe ; PERFECTION!!!!!!!!!!!! Humidity is high wet, just work them back into their original length less so keep a close eye them... T even require much kneading making it again but with all-purpose flour recipe on.! What speed with sesame seeds onto the challah is something out of ten PERFECTION! Turn out successful in my apartment think the finished product will be my new go-to for!, beat the remaining egg and brush the breads with the pictures easy challah recipe instant yeast of making your challah before it. Of pillowy with oil or nonstick easy challah recipe instant yeast spray this enough to make recipe... Other reviewers on this site and amazing!!!!!!. Never imagined that I have also used whole grain flour 4-strand braid is the!..., vegetable oil and 3 tbsp of margarine and at what speed for sure added was “! Making your challah French toast before company came x 20 minutes, rest x hour... Keep a close eye on it by dissolving it in a large pinch of.. Half it down even further puffy and doubled in size nutritional information, these figures should considered... Sweet, red, beet root challah bread that ’ s totally up to you, as well, ’! Crusty artisan bread regularly, my daughter and I made more to give you a super challah. Original length describe it as a once-in-a-while baking therapy project recipe and dough. Recipe be made in the fridge overnight after the dough and complete the first two!